Skip to main content
Universal Drugstore logo

What Is a PBM?

What Is a PBM? Understanding Pharmacy Benefit Managers and Hidden Drug Costs

Key Takeaways

  • A PBM, or pharmacy benefit manager, manages prescription drug benefits for health insurance plans.
  • PBMs negotiate rebates and discounts with drug manufacturers.
  • The largest PBMs include CVS Caremark, Express Scripts, and Optum Rx.
  • PBMs influence drug formularies, pharmacy networks, reimbursement rates, and prior authorization rules.
  • Critics say PBMs contribute to hidden drug costs through spread pricing, rebates, and a lack of transparency.
  • PBMs can affect premiums, out-of-pocket costs, and access to prescription medication.
  • Policymakers are increasingly pushing for PBM reform in Medicare Part D, Medicaid, and commercial health plans.

What Is a PBM?

A pharmacy benefit manager is a company that administers prescription drug benefits on behalf of payers such as health insurance companies, employers, unions, and government programs like Medicare Part D and Medicaid.

Shop Medications

,

PBMs act as intermediaries between:

  • Drug manufacturers
  • Health plans
  • Retail pharmacies
  • Mail-order pharmacies
  • Providers
  • Patients

Their main role is to manage pharmacy claims and control prescription drug spending for plan sponsors.

PBMs negotiate with drug manufacturers for discounts and drug rebates, create formularies, process prescription drug claims, establish pharmacy networks, and determine reimbursement rates paid to pharmacies.

Although PBMs were originally intended to reduce drug costs, their growing influence in the health care system has led to increased scrutiny.

How PBMs Make Money

PBM services generate revenue through several business practices that are often difficult for consumers to see.

Rebates From Drug Manufacturers

One of the biggest revenue sources for PBMs is rebates negotiated with drug manufacturers.

Drug companies may offer rebates in exchange for favorable placement on a drug formulary. A formulary is the list of prescription drugs covered by a health plan.

The higher a drug appears on the formulary, the easier it may be for patients to access. This can significantly increase sales for drug manufacturers.

Critics argue that this rebate system can encourage higher list prices for prescription medication because rebates are often calculated as a percentage of the drug price.

Spread Pricing

Spread pricing occurs when PBMs charge health plans more for a prescription drug than they reimburse pharmacies.

For example:

  • A PBM may charge a health plan $100 for a medication.
  • The PBM may reimburse the retail pharmacy only $75.
  • The PBM keeps the $25 difference.

This practice has become especially controversial in Medicaid programs and has prompted calls for pass-through pricing models.

Administrative Fees

PBMs may charge fees for utilization management services, pharmacy claims processing, and prior authorization programs.

These fees are often included in contracts with health plans and plan sponsors.

Ownership of Pharmacies

Vertical integration has dramatically changed the PBM industry.

Many of the largest PBMs now own:

  • Health insurance companies
  • Mail-order pharmacies
  • Specialty pharmacies
  • Retail pharmacies

For example:

  • CVS Caremark is connected to CVS Health and Aetna.
  • Express Scripts is owned by Cigna.
  • Optum Rx is part of UnitedHealth Group.

Critics say this vertical integration creates conflicts of interest throughout the drug supply chain.

What Is a Drug Formulary?

A drug formulary is a list of prescription drugs approved for coverage under a health plan.

PBMs help determine which medications appear on these formularies and how much patients pay for them.

Drugs are often divided into pricing tiers:

  • Generic drugs usually have lower costs.
  • Preferred brand-name drugs may cost more.
  • Non-preferred drugs often come with higher out-of-pocket expenses.

PBMs may also require prior authorization before certain prescription medications can be approved.

While formularies can help manage drug spending, patients sometimes discover their preferred medication is excluded or placed in a higher-cost tier.

How PBMs Affect Drug Prices

PBMs claim they help lower costs by negotiating discounts and controlling prescription drug pricing.

However, many experts argue that PBMs can also contribute to rising drug costs in several ways.

Higher List Prices

Because rebates are tied to list prices, manufacturers may increase drug prices to offer larger rebates while maintaining profits.

This can raise out-of-pocket costs for patients whose copays or coinsurance are based on list prices rather than discounted prices.

Limited Transparency

The PBM industry has long faced criticism for a lack of transparency.

Health plans, providers, pharmacies, and even policymakers may not fully know:

  • How much PBMs receive in rebates
  • How reimbursement formulas work
  • How much savings are passed through to patients

This makes it difficult to determine whether PBMs truly reduce prescription drug costs.

Pressure on Pharmacies

Independent retail pharmacies often argue that PBM reimbursement rates are too low.

Some pharmacies claim PBMs reimburse them below the cost of acquiring medications, which can threaten smaller community pharmacies.

The Largest PBMs in the United States

The PBM market is highly concentrated.

The three largest PBMs control the majority of prescription drug claims in the United States:

  • CVS Caremark
  • Express Scripts
  • Optum Rx

Together, these companies manage pharmacy benefits for millions of Americans across commercial insurance, Medicare Part D, and Medicaid.

Their massive size gives them significant negotiating power with drug manufacturers and pharmacies.

PBMs and Medicare Part D

PBMs play a major role in Medicare Part D prescription drug benefits.

They help:

  • Negotiate drug rebates
  • Manage formularies
  • Process pharmacy claims
  • Set utilization management rules

Because Medicare Part D covers millions of older adults, PBM decisions can directly affect medication access and affordability for seniors.

Federal regulators have increasingly examined whether PBM practices inflate prescription drug costs within Medicare programs.

What Is PBM Reform?

PBM reform refers to efforts aimed at increasing transparency and reducing hidden drug costs in the health care system.

Proposed reforms include:

  • Requiring pass-through pricing models
  • Limiting spread pricing
  • Increasing rebate transparency
  • Regulating reimbursement practices
  • Reducing conflicts from vertical integration
  • Lowering patient out-of-pocket expenses
  • Improving access to generic drugs

Some states have already passed PBM reform laws targeting Medicaid and commercial health plans.

Congress and federal agencies continue debating additional reforms that could affect Medicare Part D and private insurance markets.

Are PBMs Good or Bad?

The answer depends on whom you ask.

Supporters argue PBMs help:

  • Negotiate lower drug prices
  • Reduce prescription drug spending
  • Manage pharmacy networks efficiently
  • Control health care costs

Critics argue that PBMs:

  • Operate with limited transparency
  • Encourage higher list prices
  • Increase hidden fees and drug costs
  • Restrict patient access through prior authorization and formularies
  • Contribute to rising premiums and out-of-pocket expenses

The reality is that PBMs have become deeply embedded in the modern health care system, making reform complex and politically sensitive.

FAQs

What does PBM stand for?
PBM stands for pharmacy benefit manager. These companies manage prescription drug benefits for health plans, employers, Medicare Part D, Medicaid, and other payers.

What do pharmacy benefit managers do?
PBMs negotiate drug rebates with manufacturers, manage formularies, process pharmacy claims, oversee pharmacy networks, and help administer prescription drug benefits.

Why are PBMs controversial?
PBMs are controversial because critics argue their business practices contribute to hidden drug costs, lack of transparency, spread pricing, and higher out-of-pocket costs for patients.

Who are the largest PBMs in the United States?
The largest PBMs include CVS Caremark, Express Scripts, and Optum Rx. Together, they control a large share of the prescription drug market.

How do PBMs affect prescription drug prices?
PBMs can influence drug prices through rebate negotiations, formulary placement, reimbursement rates, and utilization management programs like prior authorization.

What is spread pricing in PBMs?
Spread pricing occurs when a PBM charges a health plan more for a drug than it reimburses the pharmacy and keeps the difference as profit.

What is PBM reform?
PBM reform refers to policy efforts designed to improve transparency, reduce hidden fees, regulate pricing practices, and lower prescription drug costs for consumers.

Sources